3-face assesment model

Regarding this model, I think it is a helpful process that allows us to re-evaluate existing learning instructions. However, there one problem appeared when we try to apply this model in the taxi drivers’ case. It is easy to determine the problems but we do need some discussion before we can decide whether this problem is caused by the learning process. It could be the drivers’ attitude that causes this situation, but reading the newspaper alone it is hard to determine that since we have no personal contact with the drivers and we could only analyze the article. Hence, we assume that it is caused by learning problems since the companies insist to use road safety courses to solve this problem. However, it is easier to proceed to the following steps when we decided that it should follow the discrepancy model. The problem exist may be simple because we do not have sufficient information in our hands regarding the situation. In my opinion, this model could be very useful, but we need to do appropriate research in order to gain the most benefit from it.  

Adjusted Learning Design

After

Before

Needs assessment

Basically, i fell that the three models seems quite comprehensive and complete. It explains in details how to proceed from each little details from the problem model to either discrepance model ot innovation model. My only doubt is that will it restrict the creativity of E-learning? As this models solve the solutions based on the existing problem. Of course, one cannot ignore the reality and disregard the current situation and the needs of everybody. However, i feel that this models could potentially missed some learning opportunity or potential. But maybe it's only because i have not fully understand the full potential of the whole process yet. On the whole, i think it is good that thorough evaluation and research have been done to understand the needs of the party concerned. While i agree that we should listen to the experts opinion on the discrepancy model, i think we shuold also take into the consideration of those who are non experts and listen to their views. As the experts are most likely to accept those E-learning methods better, it is important to know how those ordinary users feel about implementing E-learning course.

Learning design

Leaning design comprises of task, resources, and support. Although I think the learning design seems to help us identified the learning process, I do think it is a bit too simplified. This model seems to suggest that learning is a linear process, although we can see clearly what are the learning activities through this model, I think it is hard to decide how much the students are able to learn in the process. It does not take into the account about the students that have a hard time keeping up with the learning activities. Also, it is very task oriented and seems to be pretty rigid to me.